| Key takeaways |
|---|
| Selling a second home comes with different tax rules than selling your primary residence, including capital gains with no exclusion, possible depreciation recapture, and state-level taxes that vary depending on where your property’s located. Before you list, it's worth knowing all your options: renting, selling outright, or the middle path many owners overlook, which is selling a portion through Pacaso while keeping the share that still works for you. Pacaso connects sellers with an active pipeline of pre-qualified, high-net-worth buyers who already understand co-ownership, making it faster and simpler to sell than going the traditional route. |
Menu
- What should you consider before selling a second home?
- What are the tax implications of selling a second home?
- What are the tax considerations for selling a second home in California?
- What are the tax considerations for selling a second home in South Carolina?
- What do you need to know about selling a second home and capital gains?
- Is it better to rent or sell a second home?
- What should you know about selling a second home and buying another?
- What are some considerations for selling a second home in France?
- Your buyer is already looking: the Pacaso difference
- What are sellers seeing with Pacaso resales?
- How are Pacaso buyers different?
- How does the Pacaso selling process work?
- What makes a second home right for Pacaso?
What should you consider before selling a second home?
Before you list your second home, it helps to get clear on what you actually want out of the process. A few questions worth considering:- How often are you actually using it? If it's fewer than 16 weeks a year, the cost-per-use math tends to stop making sense pretty quickly.
- What's driving the decision? Unlocking equity, cutting carrying costs, simplifying your life, or some combination of all three?
- Does selling have to mean walking away entirely? With Pacaso, you can sell a portion of your home and keep the ownership share that still fits your life.
- What are the tax implications? Selling a second home typically triggers capital gains taxes, and where the property sits can affect how much you owe.
- How is the market behaving in your destination? Luxury second-home markets move differently than primary housing markets, and timing can matter.
What are the tax implications of selling a second home?
This is where selling a second home gets meaningfully different from selling your primary residence and where a lot of owners get caught off guard.There's no primary residence exclusion. When you sell a home you live in, the IRS lets you exclude up to $250,000 in capital gains from your taxable income ($500,000 if you're married and filing jointly) as long as you've lived there for at least two of the past five years. A second home doesn't qualify for this. The full gain is on the table.Depreciation recapture can sneak up on you. If you've rented out your second home and claimed depreciation deductions along the way, the IRS will want those back at sale, taxed at up to 25%. This is separate from capital gains, and it applies even on properties you've held for a long time.State income taxes may also apply. Depending on where the property is, you may owe state income tax on top of federal. California, for instance, taxes capital gains as ordinary income, which can push your effective rate significantly higher if you're a high earner.How long you've held your second home matters. Gains on property you've owned for more than a year are taxed at long-term capital gains rates, typically 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on your income. Hold it less than a year and it's taxed as ordinary income.The tax implications of selling a second home are specific to your situation, so it's always worth a conversation with a qualified tax advisor before you do anything.What are the tax considerations for selling a second home in California?
If your second home is in Lake Tahoe, Napa Valley, Malibu, Palm Springs, or anywhere else in California, brace for one of the highest-tax sale environments in the country.California taxes all capital gains as ordinary income. The state doesn't apply the federal preferential rates for long-term gains — it taxes everything at your marginal rate, regardless of how long you've held the property. For high earners, California's top marginal rate sits at 13.3%, which stacks directly on top of federal capital gains taxes and any applicable NIIT.There's no state-level exclusion for second homes. Just like at the federal level, California's capital gains exclusion is reserved for primary residences only.Expect withholding at closing. California requires the buyer to withhold 3.3% of the gross sale price from proceeds for nonresident sellers, unless a specific exemption applies. This gets reconciled against your actual tax liability when you file.The bottom line: California second-home sellers should be working closely with a tax professional who knows the state's rules well before finalizing anything.What are the tax considerations for selling a second home in South Carolina?
South Carolina has quietly become one of the most desirable second-home markets on the East Coast, with destinations like Hilton Head Island, Kiawah Island, and Lake Murray drawing serious luxury buyers. The good news for sellers: it's also one of the more tax-friendly states in which to sell.South Carolina offers meaningful capital gains relief. The state allows a deduction of up to 44% of net long-term capital gains, bringing the effective top rate to roughly 7% for high earners. That's a significant advantage compared to states like California.Nonresident sellers face withholding at closing. If you're not a South Carolina resident, the buyer is required to withhold 7% of the gain at closing and submit it to the SCDOR. That amount gets reconciled against your actual SC tax liability when you file, so it's not necessarily your final bill, just your deposit.As always, a South Carolina-based tax advisor will give you the most accurate picture for your situation.What do you need to know about selling a second home and capital gains?
When you sell a second home for more than you paid, that profit is a capital gain. With no exclusion available, it's fully taxable. Here's how the math works.Your gain is based on your adjusted cost basis. Start with what you originally paid for the home. Add any capital improvements, such as a new roof, a major renovation, a significant addition. Then subtract any depreciation you've claimed. What's left is your adjusted basis, and the difference between that and your sale price is your taxable gain.Higher-income sellers may owe more. On top of standard capital gains rates, the Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) adds another 3.8% for sellers above certain income thresholds. That can bring your effective federal rate on long-term gains to as high as 23.8%, before state taxes.A few strategies sellers commonly consider:- 1031 exchange: If your second home has been used as a rental or investment property and not just personal use, you may be able to defer capital gains by rolling the proceeds into a like-kind property. Personal-use vacation homes typically don't qualify, though mixed-use properties can be more nuanced. Talk to a tax professional about your specific situation.
- Installment sale: Spreading proceeds across multiple tax years can sometimes soften the impact in any single year.
- Tax-loss harvesting: If you have losses elsewhere in your portfolio, those can be used to offset gains from the sale.
Is it better to rent or sell a second home?
It's one of the most common questions second-home owners wrestle with, and the honest answer is: it depends on what you're optimizing for.Reasons to rent:- Rental income can offset your mortgage, taxes, insurance, and maintenance
- You keep the asset and stay positioned for future appreciation
- It gives you time if you're not sure you're ready to let go
- Certain rental-related expenses may be tax-deductible
- You unlock equity that can work harder elsewhere
- You're done with property management, tenant headaches, and surprise repairs
- You stop absorbing rising carrying costs year after year
- Life gets simpler, and sometimes that's the whole point
What should you know about selling a second home and buying another?
If you're selling a second home with plans to buy another, there are a few things to keep in mind before you assume the process works like it might for a primary residence.The gain doesn't automatically roll over. There's no mechanism that defers your capital gains tax simply because you reinvest the proceeds into another vacation property. The gain is recognized in the year of sale, regardless of what you do with the money next.Timing coordination matters more than people expect. Selling and buying in quick succession, especially in competitive luxury markets, means managing capital between two closings that rarely line up perfectly. Having a clear plan (and a patient advisor) helps.Some owners go a different route entirely. Rather than trading one full second home for another, more buyers are using the proceeds from a sale to purchase co-ownership shares across multiple destinations through Pacaso. It's a way to access luxury homes in the mountains, at the beach, and in wine country, at a fraction of what sole ownership in each would cost. Browse Pacaso's destination portfolio to see what's available.What are some considerations for selling a second home in France?
France is home to some of the world's most sought-after second-home markets like the Côte d'Azur, the Dordogne, the most beautiful corners of Paris. If you own property there and are thinking about selling, the tax and legal framework is quite different from a U.S. transaction.France has its own capital gains tax on non-primary residences. Known as the plus-value immobilière, it applies a base rate of 19% for income tax purposes, plus 17.2% in social charges, bringing the combined headline rate to 36.2% for most non-resident sellers. The good news is that taper relief reduces your liability the longer you've owned the property. After 22 years of ownership, you're fully exempt from the income tax portion. Full exemption from social charges kicks in after 30 years.U.S. sellers face a two-country tax situation. The U.S.-France tax treaty offers some protection against being taxed twice, but the interaction between French and U.S. obligations is genuinely complex. U.S. citizens are taxed on worldwide income, so a French property sale can generate liability on both sides of the Atlantic, though foreign tax credits can help offset what you owe in the U.S. This is an area where cross-border specialist advice isn't optional; it's essential.Everything goes through a notaire. All French real estate transactions are handled by a notaire, a state-appointed legal official who manages the transaction, calculates and withholds capital gains taxes, and ensures the whole thing is legally sound. As the seller, you're entitled to appoint your own.Don't forget currency risk. If you're bringing proceeds back to the U.S., euro-to-dollar exchange rates can meaningfully affect your net return. It's worth building that into your planning alongside the tax picture.Your buyer is already looking: the Pacaso difference
When you list a luxury second home on the MLS, you're essentially hoping the right buyer finds you. When you list with Pacaso, that buyer is often already there.Pacaso has completed over 400 resales and maintains an active pipeline of pre-qualified, high-net-worth buyers who are specifically looking for co-ownership opportunities in premium destinations. These aren't casual browsers. They're motivated buyers who have already decided that luxury co-ownership is the right model for them, and who are ready to move when the right property appears.That changes the whole dynamic of selling a second home. Instead of casting a wide net and waiting, Pacaso matches your property with buyers already in their system, while also listing on the local MLS to maximize reach. You get the depth of a dedicated buyer network plus the breadth of the open market, backed by Pacaso's brand recognition in the luxury second-home space.What are sellers seeing with Pacaso resales?
The numbers speak for themselves:| Metric | Pacaso Resales | Comparable Luxury Homes |
| Average days on market | 99 days | 120–200+ days |
| Average share price appreciation | +6% | Varies by market |
| Resales above original purchase price | 73% | — |
| CAGR (2021–2024) | 9.7% | ~5.0% (4.7% lower) |
How are Pacaso buyers different?
On the open market, your second home competes with every other luxury listing in the area. Buyers are weighing all kinds of options: whole homes, vacation rentals, properties across a wide price range.Pacaso's marketplace attracts a different kind of buyer. These are high-net-worth individuals who have specifically chosen the co-ownership model, people who want luxury second-home access without the full financial and logistical commitment of sole ownership. They've already done the research. They understand how LLC ownership works. And they're not looking for a reason to walk away.That means:- No education gap to bridge. These buyers know exactly what co-ownership is and why they want it.
- Genuine financial qualification. Pacaso's buyer pipeline is made up of vetted, motivated purchasers, not casual browsers.
- Shorter decision cycles. Because they've already committed to the model, they move faster than a typical luxury buyer would.
How does the Pacaso selling process work?
Selling a second home through Pacaso is designed to be straightforward with just seven steps. You’ll be fully supported, with Pacaso actively working to connect your property to the right buyers throughout:- Qualification: Pacaso reviews your home and assesses fit.
- Contract: You and Pacaso align on price and deal terms.
- Listing: Your home is marketed on the Pacaso marketplace and local MLS.
- Sales: Pacaso's regionally based sales team works to sell at least four shares during the marketing period.
- Transaction: Once the required shares sell, you contribute the home into a Pacaso-managed LLC.
- Management: Pacaso takes over interior design, maintenance, and property management entirely.
- Stay-ready: You show up and enjoy your home. That's it.
What makes a second home right for Pacaso?
Not every property qualifies, but if your second home is genuinely high-end and well-located, it may be a strong fit. Here's what Pacaso looks for:- High-end: Premium properties in proven second-home destinations
- Turnkey and move-in ready: No major work needed before buyers can enjoy it
- Desirable destinations: Locations with real, documented luxury buyer demand
- Premium amenities: Features that justify the co-ownership investment
- "Wow" factor: Homes that stand out even in a competitive luxury market
- Luxurious but livable: Beautiful spaces built for regular, real-life use
- Modern design: Aesthetic quality that holds its appeal over time
Ready to find out what your shares could be worth?
Right now, there are buyers in Pacaso's pipeline actively looking for luxury co-ownership opportunities in premium markets. If your second home is the right fit, those buyers could be waiting for exactly what you have.Find out what your shares could be worth, or take a closer look at how Pacaso co-ownership works, and explore homes currently in the portfolio.Selling a second home FAQs
01: Do you pay capital gains when selling a second home?
Yes. A second home doesn't qualify for the federal capital gains exclusion that applies to primary residences. Any profit from the sale is generally subject to capital gains tax at the federal level and potentially at the state level, too, depending on where the property is located. Long-term gains (on property held over a year) are taxed at 0%, 15%, or 20% federally depending on your income. Higher earners may also owe an additional 3.8% NIIT.
02: What are the tax implications of selling a second home?
The main ones include federal capital gains tax with no exclusion, possible depreciation recapture if you've rented the property and claimed deductions, state income or capital gains tax depending on location, and nonresident withholding requirements in certain states. The specifics depend on your income, how long you've owned the home, and where it's located. A qualified tax advisor should be part of the conversation before you do anything.
03: How does selling a second home in California differ from other states?
California taxes all capital gains as ordinary income, up to 13.3%, regardless of how long you've held the property. That stacks on top of federal capital gains rates and any applicable NIIT, making it one of the highest-tax states for a second-home sale. California also requires buyers to withhold 3.3% of the gross sale price from nonresident sellers at closing.
04: What do I need to know about selling a second home in South Carolina?
South Carolina is relatively seller-friendly. Long-term capital gains get a deduction of up to 44%, bringing the effective top rate to roughly 7%. Nonresident sellers are subject to 7% withholding on the gain at closing, which is reconciled against your actual SC tax liability when you file. Popular SC markets include Hilton Head Island, Kiawah Island, and Lake Murray.
05: Can I do a 1031 exchange when selling a second home?
Generally, no. Personal-use vacation homes don't qualify. A 1031 exchange requires the property to have been held for investment or business use, meeting specific IRS requirements. Mixed-use properties can be more nuanced. It's worth talking to a tax professional to see whether your situation has any eligibility.
06: Is it better to rent or sell a second home?
It depends on your goals, but there's often a third option worth considering. Renting generates income and keeps the asset but adds management burden and carrying costs. Selling unlocks equity but triggers capital gains. Selling a portion through Pacaso and retaining partial ownership gives many owners the best of both: equity freed up, hassle handed off, and continued access to a home they love.
07: Can I sell a second home and use the proceeds to buy another?
Yes, but capital gains don't automatically defer when you reinvest in another personal-use vacation property. The gain is recognized in the year of sale. (If the property qualifies as an investment property, a 1031 exchange may allow deferral. It’s highly recommended to consult a tax professional.) Some owners use sale proceeds to buy co-ownership shares across multiple Pacaso destinations, gaining access to luxury properties in different markets at a fraction of the cost of sole ownership in each.
08: What are the rules for selling a second home in France?
France taxes gains on non-primary residence sales at a combined rate of up to 36.2% (19% income tax + 17.2% social charges) for non-residents, with taper relief reducing the liability the longer you've owned the home. Full income tax exemption kicks in after 22 years; full social charge exemption after 30. All transactions go through a French notaire. U.S. sellers also need to consider their U.S. tax obligations and how the U.S.-France tax treaty applies. This is a situation where cross-border specialist advice is genuinely essential.
09: What is Pacaso's resale program?
Pacaso's resale program lets second-home owners sell through Pacaso's marketplace, with Pacaso handling the marketing, legal structure, and transaction process from start to finish. Pacaso connects sellers with a pipeline of qualified, high-net-worth buyers who are specifically seeking co-ownership. Over 400 resales completed, averaging 99 days on market, with 73% closing above the original purchase price.
010: Can I keep part of my home when I sell through Pacaso?
Absolutely. You can sell as much or as little equity as makes sense for you, keeping anywhere from ⅛ to ½ of your home, while Pacaso takes over all property management. You retain your scheduled time in the home; you just stop dealing with everything else that comes with owning it outright.
















