Sonoma vs. Napa: a wine country comparison

Published Date: May 12, 2023

Views of mountains in Sonoma
There’s so much to love about California wine country that choosing between Napa and Sonoma almost feels like choosing a favorite child. Both have their unique charms, incredible food, memorable experiences, amazing scenery and, of course, delicious wine. But if your vacation time is limited or you’re trying to decide which wine-focused location is the best for your second home getaway, something’s gotta be the tie-breaker. Here is our summary of the things you’ll love about each destination, so you can find the right wine country location for you. Cheers!

First, a word on geography

Sonoma and Napa are both less than 60 miles north/northeast of San Francisco. Both are incredible Northern California destinations which, together, welcome millions of wine-loving visitors every year. But geographical confusion abounds even among California natives. For example, both “Napa” and “Sonoma” refer to towns, counties and valleys. Here’s a quick overview.The Sonoma Valley stretches roughly 17 miles north to south, bordered by the Sonoma Mountains to the west and the Mayacamas Mountains to the east (Sonoma County itself extends west as far as the Pacific Ocean). More than 30 cities and towns are part of Sonoma County, as are roughly 425 wineries and tasting rooms. The most famous towns in Sonoma County are Sonoma and Healdsburg. The Sonoma region has a long and storied wine-producing history, spanning back to the 1850s. As far as varietals go, Sonoma County is known for its chardonnay, pinot noir (cultivated close to the cool breezes of the Pacific Ocean), zinfandel and sparkling wines. Smaller in acreage but arguably much more famous in the wine world, Napa Valley boasts 390 wineries that produce over 1,000 brands of wines. A narrow valley that is only five miles at its widest point, Napa Valley is home to four key tourist towns: Napa, Yountville, St. Helena and Calistoga. The Napa area is best known for its chardonnay, merlot and cabernet sauvignon, and is widely considered to be one of the premier wine regions. 

Benefits of Sonoma 

While Sonoma may be the less-famous cousin to world-renowned Napa, there’s much to love about spending time in Sonoma. First, Sonoma is almost double the size of Napa, which means there’s more space, more grapes and fewer crowds. The Sonoma area boasts 70,000 wine-producing acres and 13 sub-American Viticultural Areas (AVAs). Sonoma has a laid-back and casual feel, which appeals to many visitors looking for a relaxing vacation. Whether your home base is in the town of Sonoma or Healdsburg and the Russian River area, you’ll find multiple wine routes. If you’re staying in the town of Sonoma, consider renting a bike to visit close-in wineries. If more far-flung wineries are on your must-visit list, be sure to hire a car or wine tour company. Compared to Napa, Sonoma is considered the more affordable wine destination. Reasonably priced wines abound, tasting room fees won’t leave you with sticker shock, and even hotel accommodations and restaurants can be considerably more affordable in Sonoma than Napa. 

Benefits of Napa  

Simply put, Napa Valley is a bucket-list destination for wine lovers, so prepare to be wowed. With close to 400 wineries, it’s hard to know where to start. Luckily, there are multiple easy-to-navigate wine routes along Highway 29 and the Silverado Trail, so you can’t travel very far without running into yet another winery to try — don’t forget to hire a driver! Napa Valley is nothing if not luxurious, so be prepared to embrace your most upscale self during your visit. The area is brimming with premier restaurants and 95+-point wines. Whether you’re starting each day in Napa, Yountville, St. Helena or Calistoga, there are plenty of ways to indulge. Tasting room prices are often more expensive than in neighboring Sonoma, with the price per bottle following suit. Napa Valley is also home to many fine dining establishments, including the Michelin-starred French Laundry, La Toque, the Restaurant at Auberge du Soleil, Kenzo Napa and Bouchon Bistro.

Find your wine country getaway 

A weekend is never enough in California wine country. Become a regular when you buy a second home in California wine country. And when you own a Pacaso, we take care of all the management and maintenance, so you can just arrive, unpack and head out to your favorite winery. 

Jen Headshot

Jen Lyons

  • Share this post:

Featured articles

Beach in The Florida Keys
ByJen Lyons

Rocky Mountains wit snow
ByJen Lyons


Don't miss out

The best homes sell fast. See the latest listings, inspiring second homes and buying tips.

Want to chat? Contact us.